Contact Your Carrier

Hagerdon Insurance Agency Inc

Carriers Information

American Collectors Insurance logo with blue eagle and red shield emblem on white background

American Collectors

Claims Phone Number: 888-451-2858


Claims Website: Visit Website


Customer Service Website: Visit Website

Foremost Insurance Group logo with blue icon and black text on white background

Foremost

Claims Phone Number: 800-527-3907


Claims Website: Visit Website


Customer Service Website: Visit Website

Hagerty logo in black and blue on a white background

Hagerty

Claims Phone Number: 888-220-9565


Claims Website: Visit Website


Customer Service Website: Visit Website

Plymouth Rock Assurance logo in blue on a white background
KINGSTONE logo in dark green with a crown icon above the K

Plymouth Rock Assurance

Claims Phone Number: 844-242-3555



Claims Website: Visit Website

GEICO logo in blue on a white background
MetLife logo with blue and green icon and black wordmark on a white background

Geico

Claims Website: Visit Website

Statewide Underwriting Services logo in white on a blue background
MHC Mid-Hudson Cooperative Insurance logo with blue bridge graphic and text on white background

Statewide Underwriting Services 

Claims Phone Number: 518-672-4712



Claims Website: Visit Website

National General Insurance logo in orange and blue with double chevron icon

National General

Claims Phone Number: 800-468-3466


Claims Website: Visit Website


Customer Service Website: Visit Website

NYCM Insurance logo in orange and gray on a white background

New York Central Mutual

Claims Phone Number: 800-234-6926


Claims Website: Visit Website


Customer Service Website: Visit Website

Pennsylvania Lumbermens Mutual Insurance Company logo with green pine tree emblem

PA Lumbermans

Claims Phone Number: 800-752-1895


Claims Website: Visit Website


Customer Service Website: Visit Website

Preferred Mutual logo with blue and gray stylized mark and gray tagline “Live Assured”

Preferred Mutual

Claims Phone Number: 800-333-7642


Claims Website: Visit Website


Customer Service Website: Visit Website

Progressive logo in blue text on a white background

Progressive

Claims Phone Number: 800-776-4737


Claims Website: Visit Website


Customer Service Website: Visit Website

Security Mutual Insurance Co. logo with green torch emblem and “Established 1887” text

Security Mutual Insurance Co.

Claims Phone Number: 607-257-5000


Claims Website: Visit Website


Customer Service Website: Visit Website

Selective Insurance logo with black text and three yellow dots above the “V”

Selective

Claims Phone Number: 866-455-9969


Claims Website: Visit Website


Customer Service Website: Visit Website

Blue ShelterPoint logo on a white background

Shelter Point

Claims Phone Number: 800-365-4999


Claims Website: Visit Website


Customer Service Website: Visit Website

The Hartford logo with a maroon stag standing above the company name

The Hartford

Claims Phone Number: 877-805-9918


Claims Website: Visit Website


Customer Service Website: Visit Website

Travelers logo in black and red with a red umbrella over the final letter

Travelers

Claims Phone Number: 800-252-4633


Claims Website: Visit Website


Customer Service Website: Visit Website

Philadelphia Insurance Companies logo with blue Liberty Bell and tagline “A Member of the Tokio Marine Group”

Philadelphia Insurance Companies

Claims Phone Number:877-438-7459


Claims Website: Visit Website